The House of David

"dawnbreak in the west"

Monday, September 26, 2005

First they come for the passive-aggressives

I see this quote, from Pastor Niemöller, rather a lot.

In my view, the quote does a decent job of illustrating two facets of totalitarian practice. First, it details how such a movement eliminates opposition: its leaders identify organised groups who form an ideological threat to the regime, and then its storm troopers "come for" them. Second, it asserts that when the movement succeeds at clearing out its opponents, it has a freer hand at "coming for" pretty much anyone else it wants to "come for". Niemöller meant the Nazis and was attempting to warn off the Cold War faction of the US at the time; of course similar purges have proceeded under Castro, Pinochet, and Khomeini; and also (less successfully) in pre-Falklands Argentina.

In the process, Niemöller had made two assumptions: that the active party in his quote is a Rightist movement; and that the groups this movement "comes for" are static entities upon whom the innocent narrator might call for justice. Including even Communists, amazingly.

In point of fact, one must remember that the groups the Rightist movement "comes for" (Jews aside) are just as likely to "come for" the innocent as is the movement itself. At the time the Nazis were on the rise - 1923 and again in the earliest 1930s - the Communists were in cahoots with Russia. If the so-called "Soviet Union" had received half an excuse, they could be counted on to invade eastern Europe to Berlin and beyond - as they actually did from 1945-1989. And the Commies did a piss-poor job of facing up to the Nazis in the late 1930s, if I recall my history correctly.

Needless to say, if in 1917 the Russian Provisional Government had "come for" the Communists, or if the German government had "come for" the Nazis for that matter, much of the above would have been averted.

My attitude toward Niemöller's fatuousity follows:

First they came for Cindy Sheehan, then the Communists, and then the Nazis and the criminal gangs; and they came for the governmental-employee unions and the minions of ANSWER, and all those jerks from the 1960s and 1970s who fought for the enemy in World War III *knock knock* is John Kerry home; and then they came for the radical imams and racial demagogues...

... and I sat back, hoisting a frosty margarita, because I knew that at last these fuckers'd finally stopped coming after me.

posted by Zimri on 17:00 | link | 0 comments

On this site



Random crap

Powered By Blogger TM

Property of author; All Rights Reserved